Many Christians warn you not to try and get God’s approval by doing good things for Him. They will warn you that this is legalism and will feel like duty bound drudgery.
It certainly can be this for some people, no doubt about that. And, if you’re doing these things so God will save you, then yes, you are indeed missing something.
But to warn a believer not do good works for God’s approval seems really dumb.
So, why do some say this?
Mostly it rests on the idea that our identity is in Christ. You will hear, “When God looks at you, he sees Christ and not you,” or, “Christ’s works are accredited to you, so God only sees Christ’s works and not yours.” If you seek to do good for God, you are allegedly denying Christ and His provision and grace.
There are no verses in the Bible that say that Christ’s works are added to you, or that God doesn’t see you, only Christ. If these verses aren’t in the Bible, why do so many Christians maintain these ideas?
Think about it. Why would a person not want God to see their life?! Why would someone desire a doctrine that tells them what they do doesn’t matter?
The only possible answer I can come up with is that they don’t think their life is very righteous. I personally don’t mind God seeing my life. Even when I sin and I’m wrong, I want God to know that so He can correct me, maybe even discipline me, so I will knock it off.
Sin is bad. It hurts people. It’s not doing you any favors. I want God to know what I’m doing because I want Him to help me overcome these sins that so easily beset me and the weights that slow me down from pursuing Him.
The only people who desire an unseen life are those who are ashamed of their life. Men love darkness and hate the light, remember?!
Instead of developing non-biblical doctrines that convince you your sin is undetected by God so don’t worry about it, perhaps cleanse yourself from all filthiness of the flesh and spirit, perfecting holiness in the fear of God like 2 Corinthians 7:1 says.
If doing what God says feels like duty and begrudging tasks, then yes, you do have a problem! The solution to this problem is not devising doctrines that tell you not to worry about it and stop worrying about doing good. The answer is to get saved.
This isn’t my opinion, this is the Bible.
By this we know that we love the children of God, when we love God, and keep his commandments. For this is the love of God, that we keep his commandments: and his commandments are not grievous.
–1 John 5:2-3
Yes, doing good can be a checklist mentality resulting in drudgery. Doing what God says can make life harder, less fun, and potentially draining. Yet for the believer, this is all totally worth it! It doesn’t bog down the believer because the believer knows that Jesus Christ emptied himself, was made a servant, lead a hard life that wasn’t much fun, and lead to Him being called a man of sorrows acquainted with grief. He did all this for us!
As Paul said, “That I may know Him, the power of His resurrection, the fellowship of His sufferings, being made conformable unto His death.” This is not drudgery for the believer; this is what leads to spiritual fruit, holiness, and the end everlasting life.
So, yes, if doing what God says is a burden to you this should alert you to a problem. The problem is that you’re approaching God’s word and God Himself from the wrong foundation.
If you come to God on the foundation of the Gospel, truly understanding not only what Christ did for you, but also what you did with Him (Romans 6—we were crucified with Christ, buried with Christ, and raised up with Christ to new life where we now present our members as instruments of righteousness and not sin) we will desire to do what God says, not out of drudgery, but out of love.
The vast majority of false doctrine comes from people trying to deny personal responsibility. We want to sin and get away with it. We want our fleshly fun with no guilt. We want to revel in worldliness and have God smile at us too.
It doesn’t work that way. The reason you came to the Gospel to begin with, supposedly, was to be freed from sin, the world, and the flesh. The true believer desires to please God, a thing he could never do before but now through the Gospel he can!
If you struggle with the idea of pleasing God or doing things He approves of, more than likely it’s because you know your sin and you really don’t want to give it up. You want smooth words to cover your shame rather than the work required to live a new life, to work out what Christ has worked in you through the Gospel.
Thou therefore endure hardness, as a good soldier of Jesus Christ. No man that wars entangles himself with the affairs of this life; that he may please him who hath chosen him to be a soldier.
–2 Timothy 2:3-4
If you have no desire to endure hardness and live your life apart from worldliness pursuing what pleases God, then you are not saved. That doesn’t mean that for the believer enduring hardness is fun, it does mean he endures it for the joy set before him, just like Christ did coming to the cross for us.
Your attitude toward pleasing God reveals your heart. Get this issue right.