A Post to Disagree With

Seth Godin has a blog post today about doing goals that no one ever sets out to do but perhaps should. He says,

“It’s not stupid to have a stated goal of starting several ventures that will fail, or asking three stupid questions a week, or posting a blog post that the world disagrees with. If you don’t have goals like this, how exactly are you going to luck into being remarkable?”

Being stupid is a very attainable goal for me. I will accomplish this goal by doing a blog post the world will disagree with. Here goes.

The apostle Paul instructs women to be quiet in church (1 Corinthians 14:34,35; 1 Timothy 2:11-15). No one ever adheres to this instruction. Even people who pride themselves on reading the Bible literally don’t literally interpret these passages.

The explanation I always hear is that these passages are to be interpreted culturally. Paul was speaking to the culture he was in and it has no ramifications for today.

Here’s the deal, if this is cultural, consider what it does to the context. If the Holy Spirit truly does gift women to speak in church and Paul culturally tells them not to, Paul is thwarting the Holy Spirit. Paul is putting a human rule, a yoke of bondage, on people, something he specifically preaches against.

If this passage is cultural, then Paul does not listen to his own teaching, he is an opponent of the Holy Spirit, and he undermines the authority of Scripture by showing that the Bible is not God-inspired.

If that’s the case, women, feel free to speak. If it is not, I suggest women shut up.

Let the disagreement begin.

2 thoughts on “A Post to Disagree With”

  1. Heh. This cracks me up.

    If you were Bill Hybels, your book would be called, “Just Walk Across the Room and Tell a Woman to Shut Up.”

  2. I can’t believe you would say such a thing. I totally disagree. You are not stupid. Cause if you’re stupid, that makes me stupid by reading what you write. And I’m not stupid. At least, I don’t think I’m stupid. Am I stupid?

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: